A disabled Arizona father has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Round Valley Justice Court and Judge Butch Gunnels, alleging serious violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and constitutional protections.
Joseph Lathus, a mouth cancer survivor with permanent physical impairments, claims he was denied proper legal accommodations during a misdemeanor trial. Despite presenting medical records, Lathus was forced to proceed with limited assistance, including having a court clerk read his handwritten notes.
The lawsuit contends that after Lathus paid a $750 fine and filed an appeal, Judge Gunnels issued a contempt order months later, challenging Lathus's disability status without a medical evaluation. The complaint suggests this action was retaliatory, occurring after Lathus filed separate legal challenges against Apache County.
The federal lawsuit seeks injunctive relief, compensatory and punitive damages, and a jury trial. It also raises broader concerns about systemic discrimination, alleging that the justice court improperly assessed disability claims using non-medical personnel.
This case highlights potential gaps in disability accommodations within local judicial systems and the challenges faced by individuals with disabilities navigating legal proceedings. The lawsuit could set a significant precedent for disability rights and judicial accountability.
