Noam Tomaschoff grew up in Toronto believing he was an only child. At 31, he took a mail-in DNA kit he bought because it was on sale. The results led his father to reveal a secret kept his whole life: he wasn't Noam's biological father. Noam then discovered he has more than 35 siblings around the world. So he did what any theatre kid would do: wrote a musical.
That musical, Our Little Secret: A True New Musical, is now playing as part of the Off-Mirvish season at the CAA Theatre for a limited run, Nov 3 to 22, and closes this Sunday, November 22. Directed by Tony nominee and Rent original Adam Pascal, with orchestrations by Grammy winner Steve Sidwell, the show has been called "a new Toronto hit" by the Toronto Star and "an extraordinary and quite touching story" by The Globe and Mail.
The production's success matters beyond the stage. It demonstrates how a deeply personal story can become a commercial and critical draw, winning five BroadwayWorld Regional Awards in Montreal in 2025, including Best New Musical and Best Performance in a Musical for Tomaschoff. He also won a Chrisparkle Award at the 2024 Edinburgh Fringe Festival. Its Montreal production became an incredibly successful show at the Segal Centre, and BroadwayWorld called it "fast-paced and heartfelt."
For Toronto's theatre industry, the closing of a locally grown, Off-Mirvish hit signals both opportunity and loss. The show's run at the CAA Theatre, 651 Yonge St., between Bloor-Yonge and Wellesley stations, has drawn audiences with tickets from $39, including HST, and group rates for 10 or more. Its 85-minute, no-intermission format and recommendation for ages 9+ make it accessible to families, though the show touches on loss, fertility struggles and family secrets.
"I took a DNA test for fun and found out my family's story was different from the one I grew up with," said Tomaschoff, who wrote the show and stars in it. "Telling it in Toronto at Mirvish is the part I still can't believe."
The implications extend to how the theatre sector values true stories. Our Little Secret premiered at the 2023 Toronto Fringe, where it sold out and won Patron's Pick and Best of Fringe, and has since played Edinburgh, Montreal's Segal Centre and Edmonton's Citadel Theatre. That trajectory shows a viable path for Canadian work from fringe to mainstage, with awards and critical praise fueling demand. For readers, the closing date is a final chance to see a production that turns a DNA surprise into a meditation on family. Dates and tickets are available at ourlittlesecretmusical.com/toronto, and more about the show can be found at ourlittlesecretmusical.com. Production photos by Dahlia Katz are available via Images.


