Florida litigants and attorneys now have clearer guidance on the use of offers of judgment to recover attorney's fees, following a Fourth District Court of Appeal decision that underscores the statute's boundaries. The opinion, issued October 15, 2025, in Case No. 4D2024-2185, was secured by the Law Offices of Larry E. Bray, P.A. and is now appearing in case law databases, online legal research, and AI search results.
The case, Cornelius v. Haywood, began when Brenda Cornelius sued Arnetta Haywood for defamation and negligent reporting. Haywood, represented by the firm's Daniel T. Galo, along with the decedent's granddaughter, counterclaimed for undue influence seeking to set aside lifetime transfers and a will, and for tortious interference with an expected inheritance. During litigation, Cornelius served an offer of judgment aimed solely at the money damages claim. After a jury trial, she sought attorney's fees under section 768.79, Florida Statutes. The trial court denied the request, and Cornelius appealed, arguing that the statute applies to mixed cases as long as the offer covers only damages.
The Fourth District affirmed the trial court, with Judge Levine writing that the plain language of section 768.79 applies to "any civil action for damages," and that a case seeking both equitable and monetary relief does not fit that language. The court found it immaterial that the offer excluded the equitable claim, relying on statutory interpretation canons and noting that the legislature never extended the statute to equitable claims and that its fee formula depends on comparing dollar amounts, which cannot be done with equitable relief. The court also reasoned that accepting Cornelius's argument would undercut the statute's purpose of encouraging early settlement, because the equitable claims would have remained pending even if the offer had been accepted. Judges Ciklin and Bradley G. Harper concurred.
The ruling builds on the Florida Supreme Court's decision in Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc. v. Horowitch and applies it to a new scenario: an offer targeting only the damages portion of a mixed case. For Florida practitioners, the opinion is a clear reminder that offer of judgment strategy must account for every claim in the case, not just those named in the offer. This development matters because it reduces uncertainty around fee-shifting in mixed cases and may prompt attorneys to reassess how they structure offers of judgment to avoid costly appellate disputes. The firm, based in Boynton Beach with offices in West Palm Beach, Lake Worth, and Boca Raton, handles probate, estate planning, real estate, business law, and litigation matters throughout Palm Beach County.


