Researchers have identified how excessive hydrogen disrupts the microbial balance in syngas biomethanation systems, reducing methane production efficiency and triggering unexpected viral defense mechanisms. The findings, published in a 2025 early-access study (DOI: 10.1016/j.ese.2025.100637) in Environmental Science and Ecotechnology, provide crucial molecular-level insights for optimizing renewable methane production from waste gases.
Syngas biomethanation converts carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and hydrogen into renewable methane through coordinated microbial interactions. This process offers an energy-efficient, low-carbon alternative to thermochemical gas conversion, supporting circular energy systems. However, industrial operations often experience fluctuating syngas compositions, and the metabolic response to hydrogen excess has remained poorly understood until now.
The University of Padua research team used genome-resolved metagenomics, metatranscriptomics, and virome profiling to monitor microbiomes as syngas composition shifted from optimal ratios to hydrogen-rich conditions. Under near-optimal gas ratios, methane yield improved and the dominant methanogen Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus maintained stable gene expression. When hydrogen supply exceeded stoichiometric demand, methane production declined significantly.
Transcriptome analysis revealed that key methanogenesis genes—including mcr, hdr, mvh, and enzymes in CO₂-to-CH₄ reduction—were significantly downregulated under hydrogen-rich conditions. Simultaneously, M. thermautotrophicus activated antiviral defense systems, upregulating CRISPR-Cas, restriction-modification genes, and stress markers such as ftsZ. This defensive response coincided with virome mapping that identified 190 viral species, including phages linked to major methanogens and acetogens.
While some viruses showed reduced activity suggesting defense-driven suppression, others exhibited active replication patterns. Meanwhile, several acetogenic taxa—including Tepidanaerobacteraceae—enhanced expression of Wood–Ljungdahl pathway genes (cdh, acs, cooF, cooS) to boost CO/CO₂ fixation and act as electron sinks. This metabolic reprogramming indicates a shift from methanogenesis to carbon-fixation-dominant metabolism when hydrogen becomes excessive.
The authors emphasize that hydrogen excess creates a regulatory bottleneck, pushing methanogens into stress mode while enabling acetogens to take over carbon metabolism. They note that viral interactions—previously overlooked in biomethanation—play a major role in shaping community stability. The activation of CRISPR-Cas systems and phage suppression indicates a defensive state, suggesting that virome dynamics must be considered in bioreactor design.
This research provides molecular-level evidence that hydrogen oversupply can destabilize methane production, highlighting the need for precise gas-ratio control in industrial reactors. Understanding how microbial populations reprogram under stress can guide engineering of more resilient biomethanation systems, enabling consistent biomethane yields even with variable feedstocks. The insights into phage-microbe interactions further suggest potential for virome-aware reactor management strategies, including microbial community design, phage monitoring, or antiviral interventions.
The study, available at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ese.2025.100637, was supported by the European Union LIFE + program and Horizon 2020 research and innovation program. These findings support future development of carbon-neutral gas-to-energy technologies and scalable waste-to-resource platforms, addressing critical challenges in renewable energy production and industrial biotechnology.
